“Holifield’s magisterial survey of American theology from the 1630s to the 1860s . . . will remain for at least a generation the definitive chronicle of an essential aspect of American religious and intellectual history.”—Benjamin Schwarz, Atlantic Monthly
“The writing is elegant. The treatment is comprehensive, authoritative, and judicious. And the analysis is fair-minded and impartial.”—Bruce Kuklick, Books and Culture
“Monumental. . . . A brilliant exercise in historical theology . . . [and] a comprehensive survey of the most distinguished kind.”—David Hempton, Times Literary Supplement