"Legitimacy and History" by Paul W. Kahn

Legitimacy and History Self-Government in American Constitutional Theory Paul W. Kahn

Publication date:
22 Feb 1995
Yale University Press
272 pages: 235 x 156mm

This powerfully conceptualized book is both a rich intellectual history of two hundred years of American constitutional theory and an original philosophical inquiry into the possibility of self-government. Legitimate government in the United States means self-government. Yet Americans also believe that their government must be constrained by a Constitution that is now two hundred years old. Paul W. Kahn sees the development of constitutional theory as a continuous effort to resolve this conflict between self-government and history.

Rejecting the conventional idea that constitutional thought has been shaped by political and social events, Kahn argues that the history of constitutionalism has been driven by logic, not experience. He brings this perspective to the familiar events of constitutional history, including the founding, the crisis of Dred Scott, Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, the rise of the Lochner Court, the assault of legal realism, and the rise of the countermajoritarian difficulty. Kahn describes a series of conceptual stages in constitutional history. He shows that the founders' project of constitutional construction was displaced by originalism, which was in turn displaced by the idea of an evolving constitution. The turn to community in contemporary constitutional theory, Kahn argues, represents the final step in this development. At this stage, the theory and practice of constitutional law split apart. This separation is the inevitable result of the effort to do the impossible: reconcile history and self-government.

The authority of the state, Kahn concludes, is bound to history in a way that makes government by the people impossible.

Paul W. Kahn is professor of law at Yale Law School.

"I do not know of another book that participates in the constitutional dialogue with the mixture of historical perspective and acute critical eye displayed in this book. It demonstrates sweep, originality, careful criticism, and flashes of insight throughout."—Steven H. Shiffrin, Cornell University

"Legitimacy and History is a distinctive and important contribution to contemporary constitutional theory. A great strength of the book is that Kahn's discussion is so well informed historically."—Michael J. Perry, Howard J. Trienens Professor of Law, Northwestern University